What should small businesses look for when hiring a copywriter?

Great content forms the backbone of any successful digital marketing strategy, but getting it right isn’t easy. Small business content writing is a skill that can take years to develop, and if you’re not an SEO copywriting expert, trying to do it yourself can negatively impact your brand and your marketing efforts.

Beyond this, creating an effective content marketing strategy is also crucial for small businesses aiming to stand out in a competitive market. It all begins with understanding your audience – knowing their needs, interests and pain points helps you create content that truly resonates. When your content speaks directly to your customers, it builds trust, establishes your authority and ultimately drives more engagement.

Content creation isn’t a one-off task however. Regularly reviewing and updating your existing content is just as important. By conducting health checks on your blog posts, videos and infographics, you can assess what’s performing well and what’s not. This allows you to make adjustments to improve visibility, engagement and conversions. Content that’s no longer relevant or isn’t attracting traffic may need a refresh, while high-performing content can be further optimised to maximise its impact.

With a well-executed strategy and continuous monitoring, your content can become a powerful tool to grow your small business, boost online presence, and drive more conversions.

This is also where a good SEO copywriter can help, because not only can they work with you to develop an effective content strategy, they can also help you refresh existing content to make it work more effectively.

If you’re looking to create compelling, persuasive and relevant copy for your business, investing in a professional could be the best way to go.

But how do you find a great SEO copywriter? Here are some of the qualities to look out for.

First, it’s important to understand what a SEO copywriter actually does.

SEO copywriters create written content for the purpose of persuading, informing, educating or inspiring a business’ target audience. This can include writing everything from website and social media content to ads, emails, taglines, product descriptions, case studies and more.

Great copywriters know how to bring a brand’s unique values to life and tell an engaging story that carries the reader on a journey. They also craft copy that compels readers to take action – to find out more, click on something, make a purchase or revisit a brand.

Although content writing is the main service a copywriter provides, many help with other things like:

  • Refining the brand’s tone of voice
  • Suggesting relevant content ideas
  • Researching statistics and industry information
  • Editing and proofreading existing copy
  • Posting and publishing content.

RELATED: What is content marketing and why you need it for your business.

How much does an SEO copywriter cost?

This varies based on the copywriter’s experience level and area of expertise. A general copywriter with a year or two of experience will typically charge a lower rate than a copywriter with a lot of experience, or one who specialises in a niche industry such as medical writing.

As a general rule of thumb, you can expect to pay anywhere from $40/hour to $150/hour for a copywriter, depending on how much experience and specialist expertise you’re looking for.

RELATED: Evergreen content and how it can help your brand.

4 things to look for in an SEO copywriter.

  • Knowledge of your industry.

Most copywriters specialise in certain industries, meaning they’re comfortable ‘speaking the lingo’ in those areas and have a good understanding of the target audience. With this in mind, look for a copywriter that knows your industry or industries that are similar to yours.

If you’re not sure whether a copywriter is suitable for your business, you can always ask them to write a sample piece to find out – you’ll have to pay them for their time, but it’s worth it to find the right fit.

  • Recommendations.

Just like your own business, reviews say a lot about a copywriter’s capabilities, professionalism and service standard. Take a look at potential writers’ LinkedIn profiles and online portfolios to see how other clients feel about working with them – ideally, they should have at least two or three recommendations attesting to the quality of their work.

  • Writing samples.

Ask to see examples of their work – any copywriter worth their salt will have a selection ready to share with you. Look at the quality of the work as well as the relevance. Is the writing clear and engaging? Does it serve a specific purpose? Is it relevant to your industry? Answering these questions upfront will help you sort the best from the rest.

  • Digital marketing know-how.

You might think you’ve found a great copywriter, but if their experience lies in writing magazine ads or book blurbs, their skills probably won’t translate to the online realm. To that end, look for someone who is well-versed in areas such as SEO, paid ads, social media and website content writing. With this kind of background, they should have the know-how to write content that aligns with your specific digital marketing goals.

The impact of AI on content creation.

You’ve probably heard of ChatGPT – nearly everyone has. Released in November 2022, the AI content-generating app attracted over 100 million users in just five days as it went viral on social media. Since then, ChatGPT has gone from strength to strength, with 180.5 million users worldwide and 100 million weekly visits to the website.

Whilst there’s a plethora of information around ChatGPT as well as the implications this can and has had on SEO, like any tool – knowing how to use it effectively is the key to making the most of it. That is why the team at Yellow Pages have put together a great guide on this very topic. Hiring a copywriter is still often the best option, but check out this guide to ChatGPT prompts and test it out for yourself before investing in a copywriter.

Be sure to check out our recently published 2024 guide to content marketing and work with your copywriter to take your content to the next level.

Looking for expert digital marketing advice? Get in touch with Yellow Pages today.

Product enquiry.

Your business.

Your contact details.

Validating phone number...
Please enter a valid phone number.
Validating email address...
Please enter a valid email.

Best time to contact you.


This is a required field.

By entering my contact information, I consent to receiving telephone calls, text messages, and/or electronic promotional and marketing messages from or on behalf of Thryv about its products and services. I understand consent is not required to purchase goods or services and I may withdraw my consent at any time by contacting Thryv at marketing@thryv.com, or at Thryv, Locked Bag 2910, Melbourne, Vic, 3001. I further understand that I can opt out of receiving email marketing directly on Thryv's unsubscribe page and can opt out of receiving text messages by replying "STOP." For more information on how Thryv handles your personal information, please see our privacy policy.